The Roar
The Roar

Dr Rotinaj

Roar Rookie

Joined January 2025

0

Views

0

Published

425

Comments

Published

Comments

Dr Rotinaj hasn't published any posts yet

Certainly amazing…but Kohli really was/is next level in ODIs.

The record doesn’t lie.

Shock retirement call looms for Kohli with BCCI urging champion to change his mind

It’s a two person show for me in ODI batting

ABdV and Kohli.

No one else, even Richards, comes close

Shock retirement call looms for Kohli with BCCI urging champion to change his mind

Listening – for the millionth time – to that incredibly funny “That’s in Queensland” song on Youtube now…

Queenslanders just don’t get Origin: A champion Maroons team from anywhere but the Sunshine State

James Tamou is the best, because the line in the Queensland everywhere song just works so well:

“Where is Palmerston North?”
“That’s in New South Wales!”
“Queensland’s everywhere!”

Queenslanders just don’t get Origin: A champion Maroons team from anywhere but the Sunshine State

Well, Ray, we’d have to go back further then. You do not originate from birth, you originate from conception. What if you were conceived on the end of year holiday to Bali!?

You are overthinking it.

Queenslanders just don’t get Origin: A champion Maroons team from anywhere but the Sunshine State

Yeah. But unlike the A-League or Super Rugby they are dealing with a guy who simply doesn’t tolerate reneging on deals

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

Same point though. It’s not a “Melbourne” team

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

The conflict was a direct consequence of a terrorist attack from across the border which has been acknowledged by a few other nations

Yet to be proven, but ok.

Pakistan Super League joins IPL in suspending games with Aussie stars to head home as military conflict intensifies

The best clubs are the ones who don’t adopt this “proven premiership winner” dribble and instead employ the best coach they feel can win the premiership. If said coach has won a premiership in the past, then that should be considered more of a coincidence than anything else.

No coach is a “proven premiership winner” until they win one.

In fact, there is proof that employing “proven premiership winners” is actually a first class ticket to no success.

Consider that in the AFL era there are only two coaches who were “proven premiership winners” and won with a second club. Malthouse with the Pies after West Coast (but then nothing with Carlton after the Pies) and Leigh Matthews with Brisbane after Collingwood.

All the other “proven premiership winners” haven’t won another flag at another club.

Footy Fix: The Pies are fast, furious, fearless and fantastically coached - everything Fremantle aren't

Well as a standard employee occupying the role of Head coach, he can’t just be made redundant now.

Footy Fix: The Pies are fast, furious, fearless and fantastically coached - everything Fremantle aren't

Upgrading it.

WA avoided the licence fee because of a commitment to improve the ground

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

An actual WA born franchise?

Again, cherry picking.

Just cause the company is registered there doesn’t make them WA. The whole team…every player, every coaching staff was from East.

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

The storm have a great following in Melbourne even from AFL people, because they are a Melbourne team.

No they are not. They are a compromise team from a war between two media barons and populated entirely by NSW and QLD players.

They are not a “melbourne” team. You are cherry picking.

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

Things take time to build.

Not everyone is as relentlessly opposed to anything like you, 13th.

You do NOT speak for all Perth residents. You live in NZ. You haven’t lived in WA for sometime. It has changed.

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

That’s how YOU choose to see it. And that’s ok.

However, if you look at the comments made by other Perthites on the related articles over the past few weeks, none would agree with that position.

I think it’s fair enough to say you are more isolationalist than most WA residents, and that might be impacting your view on this a tad too much.

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

WA people just hate for the sake of it. It’s in their genetic coding.

You could give them a million dollars and you could guarantee the first response would not be “thanks”, but rather “let me guess, people in the east are getting more?”

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

The real winner today is the A-League and Perth Glory.

Lots of $$$ to be splashed on a substantially improved HBF park, and the A-League didn’t have to contribute a second of effort to it.

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

I wonder if this is the NRL’s long term plan all along?

Perth is a 5 year experiment to see whether there is a long term future.

But then after 5 years, not relocation per se, but expansion to the magic 20. Let the Bears “relocate” to Central Coast, and then rebadge the Perth team with something more appealing to the WA community.

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

If it was a WA team, I’d be absolutely behind it… as a relocated Sydney team, my care factor is zero.

But even if it was a WA team, it would be full of east coast players, so what difference does it really make?

Perth Bears launched as V'landys blasts 'biased ... clickbait' paper's front page

When the nuclear apocalypse strikes, the only survivors will be the cockroaches and Marnus’ test career…

Shock Marnus report surfaces ahead of WTC final as brutal call on Konstas looms

Not sure what coaches have to do with this, SCG. Indeed, not even sure what him being captain has to do with anything. If anything, him being the captain probably gave him 15-20 tests more than he deserved. He was not a good test cricketer. Lets not suddenly look at him differently because he’s retired.

As a player, his recent test form was absolutely dire. His away record is David Warner bad…worse even. He was a walking wicket…in every sense of the phrase. His fitness is so poor he can barely get faster than a Sunday stroll.

Him being 38 and demonstrably unfit also wasn’t helping any cause he convince anyone that the runs would flow again…and certainly not outside India. The next WTC cycle kicks off with 5 away tests, you cannot have that anchor dragging you back.

Rohit finally makes retirement call after SCG Test axing with Bumrah set to inherit captaincy

That’s the big difference here and one you have duly not pointed out, nor anyone else here.

Personally, I couldn’t care what Balta did. I really don’t. If the AFL wants to punish him for an act on his own time, then so be it

On the first paragraph, true. But it’s not relevant (nor is it irrelevant).

On the second paragraph, that’s the whole point isn’t it. The AFL has the right to punish any player for any contractual breach in or out of the game.

As to the final point, unlikely the AFL would be held responsible at all, if they put in measures to mitigate future repeat actions. If they do nothing, a different story of course

Anyway, I largely agree with you. My gripe is more at the incomprehensible defence RT has given Balta over the past few weeks, including the now legally untrue “he was provoked” argument

AFL News: Koch defends Rioli as more threats alleged, Dees president slams Oliver treatment, Port's mega Butters offer

That’s not because he can’t be charged with an offence. If those who he has threatened wanted to take action he very likely would be charged.

Hahahaha.

That’s not how it works. You break the law, you get charged if the DPP are inclined to proceed with it.

A victim of a robbery doesn’t get to tell the cops “it’s all good, I decline to press charges”.

You’ve spent way too much time watching American TV.

AFL News: Koch defends Rioli as more threats alleged, Dees president slams Oliver treatment, Port's mega Butters offer

Who said we should use Balta as a yardstick?

He’s an obvious recent example of someone suspended for outright thuggery in public. He also has a conviction against his name.

Rioli has done no violent act, and hasn’t even been charged. If he were to be suspended I would have said 1 week, at most. I presume you think higher.

Look at it in isolation.

Why? That’s insane. That’s not how the rule of law works. Nothing is determined in isolation. What a wally of a position.

AFL News: Koch defends Rioli as more threats alleged, Dees president slams Oliver treatment, Port's mega Butters offer

You desperately need Alex Johnston back. That man is the most underappreciated winger of our time.

He scores buckets of tries not because he just happens to be the last man to get the ball by the wing, but because his positional play is unmatched. His runs are timed perfectly.

You are missing a minimum of 6 points a game when he is injured.

NRL News: Perth Bears deal officially sealed, star Rooster set for immediate switch, Hayne cleared for comeback